16x Eval Model Evaluation

Criteria: - Side-by-side visualization without label: 8.5/10 - Baseline visualization without label: 8/10 - Horizontal bar chart (if cannot fit in the page): 7.5/10 - Has major formatting issues: 5/10 - Did not run / Code error: 1/10 Additional components: - Side-by-side visualization - Color by benchmark: +0.5 rating - Alternative ways to differentiate benchmarks: +0.5 rating - Color by model: No effect on rating - Clear labels on bar chart: +0.5 rating - Visually pleasing: +0.25 rating - Poor color choice: -0.5 rating - Minor formatting issues: -0.5 rating Additional instructions for variance: - If the code did not run or render in the first try, a second try is given to regenerate the code.

Criteria: - No text content was removed: 9/10 - Some text content was removed: 8/10 Additional components: - Left-over elements: - Left-over tables: -0.5 rating - Left-over mdx import statements: -0.5 rating - Left-over mdx components: -0.5 rating - Newline handling: - The output does not contain newlines: -1 rating - The output has 1 or more newline issues: -0.5 rating - Short code (1500 characters or less) that is correct: +0.25 rating - Verbose output: -0.5 rating Additional instructions for variance: - Each model is given two tries for this task. The higher rating will be used.

Criteria: - Code runs and gives correct (expected) output: 9/10 - The output has 1 or more newline issues: 8.5/10 - The output does not contain newlines: 8/10 Additional components: - Short code (1000 characters or less) that is correct: +0.25 rating - Verbose output: -0.5 rating - Missing export statement: -0.5 rating

Criteria: - Correctly solved the task: 9/10 Additional components: - Added helpful extra logic: +0.25 rating - Added unnecessary code: -0.25 rating - Returned code in diff format: -1 rating - Verbose output: -0.5 rating - Concise response (only changed code): +0.25 rating

Criteria: - Output only changed code (follows instructions): 9/10 - Output full code (does not follow instructions): 8/10 Additional components: - Concise response - Very concise response (<=1300 characters): +0.25 rating - Very very concise response (<=1200 characters): +0.5 rating - Verbose output (>=1500 characters): -0.5 rating

Criteria: - Bug identified and fixed: 9/10 - Bug identified but not fixed: 7/10 - Bug not identified: 1/10 Additional components: - Removes extra z-index values: +0.25 rating - Uses correct custom values syntax (e.g., z-[60]): +0.25 rating - Wrong explanation of the bug despite the correct fix: -0.5 rating Additional instructions for variance: - Each model is given two tries for this task. The higher rating will be used.

Criteria: - Provide a working method (without in keyword): 8/10 - Use in keyword: 6/10 - Did not work (Wrong answer): 1/10 Additional components: - Provides multiple working methods: +0.5 rating - Provides multiple methods - Includes one wrong method: -0.5 rating - Final answer wrong: -1 rating - Verbose output: -0.5 rating Additional instructions for variance: - Each model is given two tries for this task to account for large variance in output. The higher rating will be used.